As the amount of information collected by wind turbines continues to grow, so too does the potential of its leveraging. The application of machine learning techniques as an advanced analytic tool has proven effective in solving tasks whose inherent complexity can outreach expert-based ability. Such is the case presented by this study, in which the dataset to be leveraged is high-dimensional (79 turbines × 7 SCADA channels) and high-frequency (1 Hz). In this paper, a series of machine learning techniques is applied to the retrospective power performance analysis of a withheld test set containing SCADA data collectively representing 2 full days worth of operation at the Horns Rev I offshore wind farm. A sequential machine-learning based methodology is thoroughly explored, refined, then applied to the power performance analysis task of identifying instances of abnormal behaviour; namely instances of wind turbine under and over-performance. The results of the final analysis suggest that a normal behaviour model (NBM), consisting of a uniquely constructed artificial neural network (ANN) variant trained on abnormality filtered dataset, indeed proves effective in accomplishing the power performance analysis objective. Instances of over and under performance captured by the developed NBM network are presented and discussed, including the operation status of the turbines and the uncertainty embedded in the prediction results.