Abstract
Acetic acid is an important bulk chemical and one of the major downstream products of methanol. However, it has received less attention from an environmental sustainability perspective. Here, we evaluate the absolute sustainability of several acetic acid synthesis routes, considering both fossil and renewable feedstocks. More specifically, we studied the business-as-usual (BAU) methanol carbonylation and the novel, low technology readiness level (TRL) methane carboxylation and semi-artificial photosynthesis routes. Using process simulation and life cycle assessment (LCA), our results reveal that the alternative routes have the potential to outperform the fossil BAU in at least 14 out of the 16 evaluated impact categories. However, despite the overall improvements, their performance in SDGs 3, 6, 13, 14 and 15 remains poor in any of the studied scenarios, which could potentially be addressed by hybridizing fossil and renewable feedstocks. All in all, our analysis underscores the importance of absolute sustainability to contextualize the environmental footprint of alternative chemical synthesis pathways, going beyond climate change to embrace a broader sense of categories relative to absolute thresholds.