As pharmaceutical manufacturing is transitioning from traditional batch to continuous manufacturing (CM), there is a lack of tools for CM design and development, which can integrate drug substance and drug product unit operations for overall evaluation. Recently, a Python-based PharmaPy framework was proposed to advance the design, simulation, and analysis of continuous pharmaceutical processes. However, the initial library of models only addressed upstream drug substance processing. In this work, new capabilities, including drug product unit operations such as feeder, blender, and tablet press, have been added to the PharmaPy framework, enabling end-to-end study and optimizing the effects of material properties and process conditions on solid oral dosage products. The platform supports computational efficiency and model accuracy by allowing the development of different mechanistic and semi-mechanistic models. Sensitivity analysis is performed on the integrated end-to-end simulator to... [more]

A reinforcement learning framework is developed for the synthesis of distillation trains. The rigorous Naphtali-Sandholm algorithm for equilibrium separation modeling was implemented in JAX and coupled with the benchmarking Jumanji RL library. The vanilla actor-critic agent was successfully trained to build distillation trains for a seven-component hydrocarbon mixture. A transformer encoder structure was used to apply self-attention over the agent’s observation. The agent was trained on minimal data representation containing quantitative component flows and relative volatility parameters between present components. Training sessions involving 5·104 episodes (3·105 column designs) were typically run in under 60 minutes. While training was fast and reliable with appropriate tuning of the hyperparameters, further improvements are needed in the generalizability performance for similar separation problems.

Process synthesis is a fundamental step in process design. The aim is to determine the optimal configuration of unit operations and stream flows to enhance key performance metrics. Traditional methods provide just one optimal solution and are strongly dependent on user-defined technologies, stream connections, and initial guesses for unknown variables. Usually, a single solution is not sufficient for adequate decision-making, especially, when properties such as flexibility or reliability are considered in addition to the process economics. Wastewater Treatment network synthesis and design is a complex problem that demands innovative approaches in design, retrofits, and maintenance strategies. Considering this, an enhanced framework for improving reliability in wastewater transportation networks based on graph theory and machine learning is presented. Machine learning models were developed to predict failure probability, where the XGBoost model provided the best predictions. To select t... [more]

In this work, we introduce a quantum-enhanced reinforcement learning (RL) framework for process design synthesis. RL-driven methods for generating process designs have gained momentum due to their ability to intelligently identify optimal configurations without requiring pre-defined superstructures or flowsheet configurations. This eliminates reliance on prior expert knowledge, offering a comprehensive and robust design strategy. However, navigating the vast combinatorial design space poses computational challenges. To address this, a novel approach integrating RL with quantum machine learning (QML) is proposed. QML leverages theoretical advantages over classical methods to accelerate searches in large spaces. Built upon our prior work, the approach begins with a maximum set of available unit operations, represented in a flowsheet structure using an input-output stream matrix as RL observations. A Deep Q-Network (DQN) algorithm trains a parameterized quantum circuit (PQC) in place of a... [more]

Hydrogen (H2), as the promising alternative to fossil fuel-based energy carriers, faces the critical challenge of diversifying its sources and lowering production costs. Biogas, produced from organic waste, offers a renewable and carbon-neutral option for H2 production, but its high CO2 content requires a pre-separation process of CO2 from CH4 or specialized catalysts for use in existing reforming processes. Chemical looping reforming (CLR), as an advanced H2 production process, uses an oxygen carrier (OC) as the oxidant, allowing raw biogas to be used directly in the reforming process. Recently, numerous studies on CLR design and analysis have demonstrated their growing economic feasibility. However, deploying the CLR process in the biogas treatment industry requires further research to analyze its technical, economic, and environmental performance under target capacities and H2 purity. This study proposes biogas-based CLR processes and analyzes the capability of the processes from te... [more]

This study focuses on enhancing heat and shaft power integration within existing nitric acid production processes to optimize waste heat recovery and identify opportunities to improve process efficiency. A digital twin of the operational plant is utilized, which features a dual-stage pressure nitric acid production process with a capacity of 50 tons/h of HNO3 (100% equivalent). The authors conducted a simultaneous analysis of the thermal energy potential and the expansion capacity of tail gases to effectively fulfil the primary process's heating, cooling, and power requirements while increasing steam generation through waste heat recovery, all without compromising plant throughput. The proposed process modifications lead to a 23.8% reduction in cooling water usage and a 35.6% decrease in CO2 equivalent emissions while achieving a 13.1% increase in steam generation. These utility savings culminate in a 10.2% enhancement in plant throughput.

Process Systems Engineering (PSE) provides the advanced conceptual framework and software tools to formulate and optimise well-considered integrated solutions that could accelerate the sustainability transition within the industrial sector. The landscape of advanced PSE is poised to undertake a considerable transformation with the rise in popularity of open-source and script-based software platforms with predictive modelling capabilities based on modern mathematical optimization techniques. This paper highlights three leading equation-based platforms—IDAES, Modelica, and GEKKO-that are increasingly utilised for the modelling, simulation, and optimisation of complex systems within the advanced PSE domain, alongside the strengths and limitations of each approach. Following this, we present a framework through which emerging techniques within the domain of Software Engineering could be leveraged to address these limitations, with a vision of improving the accessibility and flexibility of... [more]

This study evaluates the introduction of Carbon Capture and Utilization (CCU) process in two Colombian refineries, focusing on their potential to reduce CO2 emissions and their associated impacts under a scenario aligned with the Net Zero Emissions by 2050 Scenario defined in the 2023 IEA report. The work uses a MILP programming tool (Linny-R) to model the operational processes of refinery sites, incorporating a net total cost calculation to optimize process performance over five-year intervals. This optimization was constrained by the maximum allowable CO2 emissions. The methodology includes the calculation of surplus refinery off-gas availability, the selection of products and CCU technologies, and the systematic collection of data from refinery operations, as well as scientific and industrial publications. The results indicate that integrating surplus refinery fuel gas (originally used for combustion processes) and HTL bio-crude off-gas (as a source of biogenic CO2) can significantl... [more]

Supplementary Material for the contribution "Synthesis of Distillation Flowsheets with Reinforcement Learning using Transformer Blocks" by Niklas Slager and Meik Franke (UTwente) for ESCAPE 35

This document contains supplementary material related to the article "Valorization of refinery fuel gas and biogenic gases from thermochemical conversion into low-carbon methanol", submitted to the 35th European Symposium on Computer Aided Process Engineering (ESCAPE 35).

All ABET-accredited engineering programs mandate a culminating major design experience based on knowledge and skills acquired in earlier course work and incorporating realistic appropriate engineering standards and multiple realistic constraints. Some chemical companies organize their Manufacturing Innovation Process into a sequence of stages which typically include Need Identification, Product Design, Basic and Detailed Chemistry, Process Design, Equipment Design, Plant Design, Detailed Engineering and Vendor Specifications, Component Acquisition, Plant Construction Planning and Execution, Operating Procedure Development, Plant Commissioning and Start-up, and Production Planning, Scheduling, and Operation. Each of these stages involve the solution of many "design" problems that could be the subject of the culminating undergraduate chemical engineering design experience... (ABSTRACT ABBREVIATED)

The overarching goal of process design (Figure 1) is to find technologically feasible, operable, economically attractive, safe and sustainable processing pathways and process configurations with specifications for the connectivity and design of unit operations that perform a set of tasks using selected functional materials (e.g., catalysts, solvents, sorbents, etc.) to convert a set of feed-stocks or raw materials into a set of products with desired quality at a scale that satisfies the demand. Process synthesis and integration can further screen, optimize and improve these pathways for given techno-econo-environmental targets or objectives. These objectives may include, but are not limited to, minimizing the overall investment and processing costs, minimizing the energy consumption, minimizing the emissions or wastes, maxim-zing the profit, and enhancing the safety, operability, controllability, flexibility, circularity, and sustainability, among others... (ABSTRACT ABBREVIATED)

In this paper, we study the design optimization of methanol production with the goal of minimizing methanol production cost. One challenge of methanol production via carbon dioxide (CO2) hydrogenation is the reduction of operating costs. The simulation of methanol production is implemented within the Aspen HYSYS simulator. The feeds are pure hydrogen and captured CO2. The process simulation involves a single reactor and incorporates recycling at a ratio of 0.995. The methanol production cost is determined using an economic analysis. The cost includes capital and operating costs, which are determined through the equations and data from the capital equipment-costing program. The decision variables are the pressure and temperature of the reactor contents. The optimization problem is solved using a derivative-free algorithm, pyBOUND, a Python-based black-box model optimization algorithm that uses random forests (RFs) and multivariate adaptive regression splines (MARS). The predicted minimu... [more]

Initial design stages are inherently complex and often lack comprehensive information, posing challenges in evaluating sustainability metrics. Machine Learning (ML) emerges as a valuable solution to address these challenges. ML algorithms, particularly effective in predicting environmental impacts of new chemicals with limited data, enable more informed decisions in sustainable design. This study focuses on employing ML for predicting the environmental impacts related to human health, ecosystem quality, climate change, and resource utilization to aid in early-stage environmental impact assessment of chemical processes. The effectiveness of the ML algorithm, eXtreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) tested using a dataset of 350 points, divided into training, testing, and validation sets. The study also includes a practical application of the model in a cradle-to-cradle LCA of N-Methylpyrrolidone (NMP), demonstrating its utility in sustainable chemical process design. This approach signifies... [more]

Biogas is often considered as a source of renewable energy, for heat and power production. However, biogas has greater promise as a source of concentrated CO2 in addition to methane, making it a rich supply of carbon and hydrogen for the generation of fuel and chemicals. In this work, we use the concept of attainable region in the enthalpy-Gibbs free energy space to identify opportunities for effective biogas valorization that maximizes the conversion of CO2. The AR concept allows us to study a chemical process without knowing the exact reaction mechanism that the species in the process use. Deriving Material Balance equations that relate a reactive process's output species to its input species is sufficient to identify process limits and explore opportunities to optimize its performance in terms of material, energy, and work. The conversion of biogas to valuable products is currently done in two steps; the high temperature and endothermic reformer step, followed by the low temperatur... [more]

Hydrogen, as a clean and versatile energy carrier, holds immense promise for addressing the world’s growing energy and environmental challenges. However, hydrogen-based energy systems face challenges related to efficient storage methods, energy-intensive production, refueling processes, and overall cost-effectiveness. To solve this problem, a superstructure was developed that integrates overall technologies related to hydrogen energy transportation. This study synthesizes process pathways for hydrogen energy transportation method including energy carrier production, storage, and refueling, based on the developed superstructure. The techno-economic analysis was conducted to evaluate the performance of each transportation pathway and compare it with conventional fossil fuel transportation system. Process performance criteria, including unit production cost (UPC), energy efficiency (EEF), and net CO2 equivalent emissions (NCE), serve as indicators for process performance. By comparing tec... [more]

In this work, we present a follow-up work of reinforcement learning (RL)-driven process design using the Institute for Design of Advanced Energy Systems Process Systems Engineering (IDAES-PSE) Framework. Herein, process designs are generated as stream inlet-outlet matrices and optimized using the IDAES platform, the objective function value of which is the reward to RL agent. Deep Q-Network is employed as the RL agent including a series of convolutional neural network layers and fully connected layers to compute the actions of adding or removing any stream connections, thus creating a new process design. The process design is then informed back to the RL agent to refine its learning. The iteration continues until the maximum number of steps is reached with feasible process designs generated. To further expedite the RL search of the design space which can comprise the selection of any candidate unit(s) with arbitrary stream connections, we investigate the role of RL reward function and... [more]

In this paper, a hybrid heuristic rule-based and deterministic optimization-driven process decision framework is presented for the analysis and optimization of process flowsheets for end-to-end optimal (E2E0) pharmaceutical manufacturing. The framework accommodates various operating modes, such as batch, semi-batch and continuous, for the different unit operations that implement each manufacturing step. To address the challenges associated with solving process synthesis problems using a simulation-optimization approach, heuristic-based process synthesis rules are employed to facilitate the reduction of the superstructure into smaller sub-structures that can be more readily optimized. The practical application of the framework is demonstrated through a case study involving the end-to-end continuous manufacturing of an anti-cancer drug, lomustine. Alternative flowsheet structures are evaluated in terms of the sustainability metric, E-factor while ensuring compliance with the required pro... [more]

Superstructure optimization for process synthesis is a challenging endeavour typically leading to large scale MINLP formulations. By the combination of phenomena-based building blocks, accurate thermodynamics, and structural screening we obtain a new framework for optimal process synthesis, which overcomes prior limitations regarding solution by deterministic MINLP solvers in combination with accurate thermodynamics. This is facilitated by MOSAICmodeling’s generic formulation of models in MathML / XML and subsequent decomposition and code export to GAMS and C++. A branch & bound algorithm is implemented to solve the overall MINLP problem, wherein the structural screening penalizes instances, which are deemed nonsensical and should not be further pursued. The general capabilities of this approach are shown for the distillation-based separation of a ternary system.

We present new modifications to superstructure optimization paradigms to i) enable their robust solution and ii) extend their applicability. Superstructure optimization of chemical process flowsheets on the basis of rigorous and detailed models of the various unit operations, such as in the state operator network (SON) paradigm, is prone to non-convergence. A key challenge in this optimization-based approach is that when process units are deselected from a superstructure flowsheet, the constraints that represent the deselected process unit can be numerically singular (e.g., divide by zero, logarithm of zero and rank-deficient Jacobian). In this paper, we build upon the recently-proposed modified state operator network (MSON) that systematically eliminates singularities due to unit deselection and is equally applicable to the context of both simulation-based and equation-oriented optimization. A key drawback of the MSON is that it is only applicable to the design of isobaric flowsheets... [more]

This work presents an overview of the path towards the use of renewable and nonconventional resources for a sustainable chemical and process industry. The aim is not only to lead the way to meet the sustainable development goals but also to maintain the style and quality of life achieved by the technologies and products developed within this sector. Alternative raw materials are to be used and processed differently while a new paradigm for utilities is to be established. The development of technologies and their deployment faces several barriers that we as process engineers can help overcome by providing insight into the alternatives, the thresholds to achieve to become competitive, and strategic analyses.

In designing low-carbon processes, the unintended emission of CO2 remains a significant concern due to its global environmental impact. This paper explores carbon management within chemical processes, specifically examining the correlation between the process material balance (PMB) and CO2 emissions to understand and identify the potential for reducing these emissions. We interrogate the foundational issue of carbon discharge by analyzing the interplay among mass, energy, and entropy balances, which collectively influence the PMB. We introduce the concept of the Target Material Balance (TMB), which represents the material balance of a process corresponding to minimum CO2 emissions within the given constraints. We could ask what decisions in the design and operation of processes result in higher CO2 emissions than the TMB. We will focus on the interaction between reactions and recycles and how the arrangement of recycles in processes can inadvertently change the PMB, thereby increasing... [more]

Following the discovery of the least squares method in 1805 by Legendre and later in 1809 by Gauss, surrogate modeling and machine learning have come a long way. From identifying patterns and trends in process data to predictive modeling, optimization, fault detection, reaction network discovery, and process operations, machine learning became an integral part of all aspects of process design and process systems engineering. This is enabled, at the same time necessitated, by the vast amounts of data that are readily available from processes, increased digitalization, automation, increasing computation power, and simulation software that can model complex phenomena that span over several temporal and spatial scales. Although this paper is not a comprehensive review, it gives an overview of the recent history of machine learning models that we use every day and how they shaped process design problems from the recent advances to the exploration of their prospects.

Sustainability of the chemical and materials industry (CMI) requires it to achieve net-zero emis-sions of greenhouse gases and other resources while making decisions that have a net-positive impact on nature and society. Many corporations, nations, and universities have pledged to meet such goals but systematic models, methods, and tools to guide this transition are missing. We pre-sent a framework to meet this need. It involves developing a comprehensive, open access model of the global CMI. In addition to existing technologies, this model includes emerging alternatives for renewable energy, circularization, and carbon capture, utilization and storage. Systematic methods help identify innovation opportunities and develop roadmaps that account for long-term changes such as technology evolution and climate change. Meeting the goal of net-zero emis-sions requires inclusion of life cycle impacts. Nature-positive decisions need to encourage eco-logical protection and restoration. Thi... [more]

The development of a bio-based economy has its foundations in the development of efficient processes to optimize biomass potential. In this context there are a multitude of molecules that can be either synthetized or recovered from biomass, among those the so-called 12 building-blocks reported by the US Department of Energy. Even if their identification and importance is clearly defined, research efforts concerning the purification or separation of these platform molecules are limited. To fill this gap, different configurations for the purification of levulinic acid recovered from lignocellulosic biomass are examined and compared in this work. In particular, hybrid configurations obtained by the combination of liquid-liquid extraction and distillation have been considered. It was demonstrated how a deep understanding of the subspace including all extraction-assisted simple column distillation configurations represents a fundamental step in the synthesis of different process alternative... [more]